Sidecrafts

Free tool · Etsy and Shopify fees (US)

Etsy vs Shopify fee calculator

Put in your price and how many sales you expect a month. See what each platform takes, what’s left for you, and from how many sales your own store starts to cost less.

US fees from Etsy’s own pages and Shopify’s published pricing. Updated November 2026

Short answer

On a $25 item Etsy takes about $2.88 per sale and nothing a month. Shopify Basic takes about $1.08 per sale with Shopify Payments, plus $39 a month ($29 billed yearly). So Shopify costs less from about 22 sales a month (17 on yearly billing), before what you spend to bring buyers to your own store. On Etsy, its search brings them.

Your sales

More options
A month, before your own costs
Etsyleft for you
Shopifyleft for you

Etsy fees per sale
Shopify card fee per sale, 2.9% + 30¢
Shopify plan and other costs a month
Bringing buyers to your store a month

Every Etsy fee on one sale →

US sellers, one item per order, Shopify Payments. Not included: Etsy’s one-time setup fee, Shopify’s trial months, Etsy Ads you choose to run, and your cost of making the item. An estimate, not financial advice.

How the comparison works

Etsy has no monthly fee. Each US sale pays $0.20 for the listing, 6.5% of the price and shipping, and 3% + $0.25 for payment processing on the total the buyer pays. A sale that comes from Etsy’s Offsite Ads pays another 15% (12% for shops above $10,000 a year).

Shopify Basic costs $39 a month, or $29 a month billed yearly. With Shopify Payments each online card sale pays 2.9% + 30¢, and there is no transaction fee on top. So the plan is a fixed cost, spread over however many sales you make that month.

That’s why the answer depends on your sales. With few sales, the monthly plan makes each Shopify sale expensive. With many, Shopify’s lower card fee wins. The calculator finds the point where they meet.

Fees per sale on a $25 item

Free shipping, 7% sales tax, no Offsite Ads, Shopify Basic at $39 a month spread over your sales. Before the cost of bringing buyers to your own store.

Sales a monthEtsy, per saleShopify Basic, per saleCosts less
5$2.88$8.88Etsy
10$2.88$4.98Etsy
20$2.88$3.03Etsy
30$2.88$2.38Shopify
50$2.88$1.86Shopify

The part fees don’t show: a new Shopify store starts with no visitors. Every buyer comes from something you do, like posting, running ads or building an email list. Put that cost in the calculator above and the point where Shopify wins moves much further out. For a first shop, that’s why we start on Etsy and add an own store later. Etsy or Shopify for your first shop? →

Questions about Etsy and Shopify fees

Is Shopify cheaper than Etsy?

Per sale, yes: on Shopify Basic with Shopify Payments you pay 2.9% + 30¢, against 6.5% + 3% + $0.45 on Etsy. But Shopify Basic also costs $39 a month ($29 billed yearly) whether you sell or not, and you bring every buyer yourself. On a $25 item Shopify costs less from about 22 sales a month, before what you spend on ads.

How many sales a month before Shopify is worth it?

It depends on your price. With Shopify Basic at $39 a month and 7% sales tax: from about 49 sales a month on a $10 item, 22 on a $25 item and 12 on a $50 item. On yearly billing ($29 a month): about 36, 17 and 9. Every dollar you spend to bring a buyer to your own store pushes that number up.

Does Shopify charge transaction fees?

Not when you use Shopify Payments: you pay only the card rate, 2.9% + 30¢ online on Basic. With another payment provider, Shopify adds 2% on Basic, on top of that provider’s own fee.

Is the Shopify Starter plan still available?

Not for new stores. Shopify’s Help Center said in November 2026 that the $5 Starter plan isn’t available to new stores, and the US pricing page now starts with Basic.

Does Etsy charge a monthly fee?

No. Etsy charges $0.20 per listing, 6.5% of the price and shipping, and 3% + $0.25 for payment processing (US). New shops pay a one-time setup fee of about $15–29. Offsite Ads add 15% only on sales those ads bring (12% for shops above $10,000 a year).

Read next: Etsy vs Shopify: when is the money deposited?

Check the sources Elias uses for these fees8 sources, checked November 2026

Etsy fees come from Etsy’s own pages. Shopify’s pricing page couldn’t be read directly from where we check, so its figures are cross-checked in recent reviews dated below. Fees and plans change: check both platforms before you choose.

Etsy

Shopify

Don’t fill your head with it. Elias knows where you sell and runs these numbers for every price you set in Sidecrafts.

Feeling it’s a lot?

Yes, it’s a lot. That’s exactly what Elias is for.

Elias, your mentor inside Sidecrafts, already knows everything on this page. You don’t have to keep any of it in your head.

  • He knows it allEtsy’s rules, fees, partners and trends, checked and kept up to date as they change.
  • He stops you in timeBefore you publish, print or set a price, he flags what would go wrong.
  • He helps where it countsOne step at a time. The creative part stays yours.
Start your first product with Elias and help us launch Sidecrafts faster

Sidecrafts is a new app we’re building now. Your answers tell us what to build first.