Sidecrafts

SidecraftsGuidesEtsy or Shopify

Guide · Where to sell

Etsy or Shopify for your first shop?

Both let you sell your designs. The difference is who brings the buyers, what you pay every month, and who owns the customer. An honest comparison with 2026 numbers, and why we start on Etsy.

US sellers · Checked November 2026

Written with AI help. Read and edited by Dinah, founder of Sidecrafts, on November 12, 2026.

Side by side

Etsy and Shopify for a small creative shop, US, November 2026
QuestionEtsyShopify
Who brings the buyersEtsy: about 88 million active buyers search thereYou: ads, social media, search, email
Monthly cost$0Basic $39, or $29 a month billed yearly
To openA one-time setup fee of about $15–29A 3-day trial, then $1 a month for 3 months
Per listing$0.20$0
Per sale6.5% + 3% + $0.252.9% + 30¢ on Basic with Shopify Payments
Etsy’s own ads15% on sales they bring; 12% and mandatory above $10,000 a yearNone, but you pay for your own ads
Your customersEtsy’s buyers, inside EtsyYours: you can email them
RulesEtsy’s creativity standards and photo rulesShopify’s terms; far fewer listing rules
CompetitionAbout 5.8 million other sellers in the same searchYour own store, but every store online

The real difference: who brings the buyers

On Etsy, people are already searching for “christmas stickers” or “wall art for nursery”. A good listing can be found in its first weeks. A new Shopify store starts with no visitors at all: every buyer comes from something you do, like posting, running ads or building an email list. With a few hours a week, that is the hardest part to do well.

For a first shopEtsy is where you learn what sells. Shopify is where you grow what already sells.

When does your own store pay off?

Shopify’s fees per sale are lower, but the monthly plan is the same whether you sell or not. Here is a $50 sale, US, 7% sales tax, Shopify Basic at $39 a month, without Etsy’s Offsite Ads:

Fees on one $50 sale, including the monthly plan spread over your sales
Your salesEtsyShopify Basic
5 sales a month$5.30$9.65
10 sales a month$5.30$5.75
20 sales a month$5.30$3.80
50 sales a month$5.30$2.63

Shopify gets cheaper per sale from about 12 sales a month. Try your own price and sales in the Etsy vs Shopify fee calculator → That doesn’t count what you spend to bring visitors to your own store, which on Etsy you don’t have to. When Etsy’s Offsite Ads bring the sale, Etsy takes another 15% ($7.50 on $50).

Start on Etsy if

This is your first shopYou want to find out what sells before you spend on a store.
You have a few hours a weekNo time for ads and social media on top of making things.
You sell small digital or print itemsStickers, printables, print-on-demand: what Etsy buyers search for.

Add your own store when

Buyers come backRepeat customers you’d like to reach by email.
You pass about $10,000 a yearEtsy’s Offsite Ads become mandatory at 12% of the sales they bring.
You already have followersAn Instagram audience can follow you to your own store. Shopify’s $5 Starter plan for social selling is closed to new stores, so plan for Basic.

Most sellers who grow keep both: Etsy finds new buyers, and their own store keeps the ones who come back. Moving away from Etsy too early is a common mistake, because building your own traffic often takes 6–12 months.

Start where the buyers already areElias, your mentor inside Sidecrafts, plans your first Etsy product around your style and your week. About 3 minutes.
Start with Elias →

Questions people ask

Should I start on Etsy or Shopify?

For a first shop, Etsy. About 88 million active buyers already search there, it has no monthly fee, and you learn what sells before you spend on your own store. Add Shopify later, when you have repeat buyers or your own audience.

Is Shopify cheaper than Etsy?

Per sale, yes: 2.9% + 30¢ on Shopify Basic against 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 on Etsy. But Shopify Basic costs $39 a month (or $29 billed yearly) whether you sell or not. On a $50 item it gets cheaper from about 12 sales a month, before the cost of bringing visitors yourself.

Can I sell on both Etsy and Shopify?

Yes, and many growing sellers do: Etsy brings new buyers, your own store keeps repeat ones. Keep stock in sync if you sell physical items in both places.

Does Sidecrafts work with Shopify?

Sidecrafts starts on Etsy, where beginners find buyers fastest. We are looking at help with your own store for sellers who already have sales.

Read next: Etsy vs Shopify: when is the money deposited? · Where to sell your designs: Etsy, Redbubble and more · Should you leave Etsy in 2026?

Check the sources behind this page9 sources, checked November 2026

Buyer numbers from Etsy’s Q3 2026 results; fees from Etsy’s policies and Shopify’s published pricing.

Buyers and sellers

Fees

A note on what the data can and can’t say. Shopify’s prices vary by country and change over time; check shopify.com before you choose a plan. The fee table is an example.

Start where buyers already search

Your first product, on Etsy, with Elias

Sidecrafts helps you start a small creative business on Etsy while you keep your job: your own designs, a few hours a week, with Elias, your mentor inside Sidecrafts, at every step.

  • No need to quitA plan built around the hours you actually have.
  • Your taste, your designsAI can help you draw. The ideas and the choices stay yours.
  • Honest about moneyWe show what one sale leaves after fees, and help you find the style that makes people buy.
Start your first product with Elias About 3 minutes. Free to try. We never ask for your card.