Sidecrafts

SidecraftsGuidesShould you leave Etsy?

Guide · Where to sell

Should you leave Etsy in 2026?

Higher fees, Offsite Ads, new rules on AI and production partners, more sellers in every search: plenty of people are talking about moving to their own website this year. Before you go, here is what you would lose, what it costs, and a checklist for when it’s time and when it’s too early.

Checked November 2026 · Fees for US sellers

Written with AI help. Read and edited by Dinah, founder of Sidecrafts, on November 16, 2026.

The short answerMost sellers who grow don’t leave Etsy. They add their own store: Etsy keeps bringing new buyers, and the store keeps the ones who come back.

Why sellers are thinking about leaving

Fees add up$0.20 per listing, 6.5% per sale and 3% + $0.25 for payment in the US. When Etsy’s Offsite Ads bring the sale, another 15%, or 12% and mandatory once you pass $10,000 a year.
Stricter rulesIn 2026 Etsy asks sellers to be clearer about production partners and AI-made items, and has pulled back on some listings it used to allow.
More competitionAbout 5.8 million active sellers share the same searches, and new listings arrive every day.

What you lose when you leave

What stays on Etsy if you move to your own website
On Etsy you haveOn your own site you start with
About 88 million active buyers already searchingNo visitors until you bring them
Your reviews and sales countNo reviews; they stay on Etsy
Etsy’s buyers, inside EtsyNo customer list: Etsy’s policy says you may not add Etsy members to your mailing list
Checkout, taxes and buyer trust handled by EtsyA store, payments and policies you set up and pay for

The last row matters most. Etsy’s rules say buyer details are for Etsy-related communication only, and sellers must not steer buyers to buy outside Etsy. So the people who bought from you on Etsy don’t move with you. Your own list has to be built from your own channels.

It may be time to add your own store if

You have steady salesOn a $50 item, Shopify Basic gets cheaper per sale than Etsy from about 12 sales a month. Check your numbers →
You pass about $10,000 a yearOffsite Ads become mandatory, at 12% of the sales they bring.
Buyers come backRepeat buyers and custom requests are the people a store and newsletter are for.
You have an audience elsewhereInstagram, Pinterest or a newsletter that people joined themselves can send visitors to your store.
You have time for marketingBuilding your own traffic often takes 6–12 months of steady posting, email or ads.

It’s too early if

You’re still looking for your first salesIf Etsy buyers aren’t finding or choosing a product, an empty website won’t fix that. Work on the product, photos and listing first.
You have no audience yetWithout followers or a list, every visitor to your own store costs ads or months of work.
You have a few hours a weekRunning a store and its marketing is a second job on top of making things.

Leave or add?

Two ways to grow beyond Etsy
Leave EtsyKeep Etsy and add a store
New buyersOnly from what you doEtsy search plus what you do
Monthly costYour store planYour store plan; Etsy has no monthly fee
RiskSales can drop for monthsEtsy keeps paying while the store grows
WorkOne shopTwo shops to keep in sync

For most small creative shops, adding is the safer order. You can still move more of your sales to your own store later, once it has steady visitors.

If you add your own store: first steps

  1. Start a list of your own. A newsletter sign-up on your website and social profiles, with something small and useful for joining. Not from your Etsy orders.
  2. Check the costs first. Compare a store plan with your Etsy fees at your real price and sales. Etsy vs Shopify fee calculator →
  3. Move your best sellers first. Start with what already sells, not your whole shop.
  4. Keep one name and look. Use the same shop name, logo and photo style, so people who know you can find you.
  5. Give it time. Judge your store after 6–12 months, and keep Etsy running meanwhile.
Still looking for the product that sells?Elias, your mentor inside Sidecrafts, helps you find what buyers already want and make your own version of it. About 3 minutes.
Start with Elias →

Questions people ask

Is it worth leaving Etsy in 2026?

For most small sellers, no: Etsy still brings buyers you would otherwise have to find and pay for yourself. It can be worth adding your own store when you have steady sales, buyers who come back, or an audience outside Etsy. Moving everything at once is the risky part.

Can I take my Etsy customers with me?

Not directly. Etsy’s seller policy says you may not add Etsy members to your email or mailing list, and buyer details may only be used for Etsy-related communication. Your own customer list has to come from your own channels: your website, Instagram, Pinterest or a newsletter people sign up for themselves.

Can I send Etsy buyers to my own website?

Etsy’s rules say sellers must not facilitate off-platform transactions, including through listings and messages. Build traffic to your own store from places you control instead, and keep Etsy orders on Etsy.

How long does it take for my own store to get sales?

Often 6–12 months to build steady traffic of your own. That is why many sellers keep Etsy running while their store grows.

Does Sidecrafts help with my own store?

Sidecrafts starts on Etsy, where beginners find buyers fastest. Help with your own store for sellers who already have sales is something we are building towards.

Read next: Etsy or Shopify for your first shop? · Etsy vs Shopify: when is the money deposited? · Where to sell your designs

Check the sources behind this page9 sources, checked November 2026

Rules quoted from Etsy’s own policies; buyer numbers from Etsy’s Q3 2026 results; Shopify prices from published pricing.

Etsy’s rules

Buyers and sellers

Fees

A note on what the data can and can’t say. We found plenty of articles about sellers leaving Etsy, but no reliable numbers on how many actually leave. Fees and rules change; check Etsy’s and your store platform’s current pages before you decide.

Start where buyers already search

Your first product, on Etsy, with Elias

Sidecrafts helps you start a small creative business on Etsy while you keep your job: your own designs, a few hours a week, with Elias, your mentor inside Sidecrafts, at every step.

  • No need to quitA plan built around the hours you actually have.
  • Your taste, your designsAI can help you draw. The ideas and the choices stay yours.
  • Honest about moneyWe show what one sale leaves after fees, and help you find the style that makes people buy.
Start your first product with Elias About 3 minutes. Free to try. We never ask for your card.