How this test workedI started from zero, like any new user: the same onboarding, the same questions, no shortcuts. Elias, the mentor inside Sidecrafts, is still being built, so for now his part was played by hand: an AI assistant following the same steps the app will. I wrote down every moment I got stuck.
Days7
Listings live16+
Times I got stuck40+
Product lines3
First listing≈ 8 hours
Day 1: “I like landscapes” is not a product
The onboarding took me 8–10 minutes, and it ended with an idea I liked: a set of small square prints for a hallway, light colors, landscapes, in matching black frames. Then I stopped. I had an idea, but no idea what to actually make.
Where I got stuck“A set of landscape prints” could be anything. I didn’t know how many, what size, or how to make them look like they belong together.
How Elias helpedHe turned the idea into a brief I could follow: four prints in a row, 10×10 inches, different places, one palette and style, and a little black in each print so it works with black frames. That brief became HOME: four letters hidden in real places from my travel photos.
Days 2–3: the drawing that wouldn’t come out right
I wanted to turn my photos into clean line drawings with soft color. The AI drawing tool kept giving me pencil engravings, in the wrong shape.
Where I got stuckAfter a dozen tries I had nothing I could use, and I started to think the whole idea wouldn’t work.
How Elias helpedHe told me to stop describing the style in words and give the tool one reference picture instead. With the reference, the style came out right on the first try. He also caught that my first two letters didn’t match each other before they went into a set.
Then came everything a listing needs: mockups, a picture of what you get, a printing guide, a title, 13 tags, a price. Elias prepared each piece and I decided. The first listing still took about eight hours. Each one after it took a fraction of that.
Day 3: a second idea I wouldn’t have found alone
Where I got stuckEvery new letter needed a good photo from a trip. I couldn’t grow a shop that way.
How Elias helpedHe suggested a second product that didn’t depend on my photos, built on something else I love: reading. That became Your Reading Journey: bookshelf trackers you color in, literary maps with the books behind each place, reading-journal stickers and menus for book lovers. It turned out to be the stronger line, with a clear buyer: people who host book clubs.
Day 4: published, and in the wrong places
I published 16 listings in one day and felt done. Elias didn’t let me stop there.
Where I got stuckI had no idea whether Etsy understood what I was selling. Everything looked fine from inside my shop.
How Elias helpedHe checked which products Etsy showed next to each of mine. A menu that started with “Funny” sat among joke gifts. Postcards with “gift” first sat among gifts in general. My letter prints sat next to children’s alphabets. He rewrote the titles the way buyers actually search, and we fixed all of them the same day.
He also asked me to print every product before anyone bought it. At the print shop it was hard to see where to cut the letter posters, so Elias added cut lines to every file that evening.

Stuck on your own idea?Elias starts with your style, not a blank page. About 3 minutes.
Start with Elias →
Days 5–7: following the buyer
Where I got stuckI knew who my buyer was, but not what else to make for her.
How Elias helpedHe walked through her evening: invitations, a menu, questions, a book swap, something to take home. That became a Book Club Night Kit, then a Christmas Book Club Kit with a menu written for A Christmas Carol, and Christmas cards from my winter walks. He also set up season discounts and a “You may also like” page inside the kit, so a buyer can come back.
Elias wasn’t perfect. Once he showed me drafts without asking first who would buy them, and I had to ask the obvious question myself. Every time that happened, it became a rule in the product, so the next person doesn’t have to.
We also put five designs on Redbubble to test a print-on-demand marketplace. When I asked whether a literary map is worth anything without the book list that comes with it on Etsy, Elias added the book under every place on the map. I wrote up how that route works in Where to sell your designs.
What I’d tell myself on day one
Getting stuck is the normal partI got stuck more than 40 times in a week. Not one of those moments needed talent. Each needed the next small step.
Your second idea may be the better oneI started with travel prints. The products with a clear buyer came from reading.
Check your neighborsSearch for your product the way a buyer would, and look at what Etsy puts next to it. If the neighbors are wrong, the title is wrong.
What’s next
Next week: whether video on Pinterest brings visitors to a shop, whether Redbubble sells anything at all, and what happens when two small shops send buyers to each other. You can see the shop as it is today at WhereIWalk on Etsy.
Free guide + weekly Etsy trends
Get “December on Etsy” free
What shoppers search for before Christmas and 10 things you could make in time, in a 4-page PDF. Then every week: what people searched for on Etsy, and what you could make from it.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy
Start where buyers already search
Your first product, with Elias
Sidecrafts helps you start a small creative business while you keep your job: your own designs, a few hours a week, with Elias, your mentor inside Sidecrafts, at every step.
- No need to quitA plan built around the hours you actually have.
- Your taste, your designsAI can help you draw. The ideas and the choices stay yours.
- Honest about moneyWe show what one sale leaves after fees, on each platform.
Start your first product with Elias
About 3 minutes. Free to try. We never ask for your card.